ADVERTORIAL
My mother shut a half sewn book in a drawer in 2019. Last Tuesday she finished it.
She spent twenty years telling me that crooked stitching is what makes a thing handmade. Then she took that book back out of the drawer. If you punch your own signatures, this is the part nobody explained to me.
Told in her own words. Published 23 September 2025.
"Don't say anything yet."
That is how my mother started the message last Tuesday. Nothing good has ever started with don't say anything yet.
"What's wrong?" I wrote back.
"Nothing is wrong. I finished the Coptic. The one from 2019. Come and look at the stitching."
I read it four times before I put my shoes on.
That message needed explaining, coming from her. She taught me to sew a signature before I could do long division, she has bound more books than I ever will, and every time I held up something crooked she was the one who told me that was the point.
She had never once asked me to come and look at her stitching.
The wobble has two halves, and I had only ever been fixing one
I make simple journals and I rebind books I love, at a kitchen table, and I learned every part of it from her. Years ago I wrote in a group: "I’m going to need a screw punch now, these books are so fun to make!" I meant all of it.
Then there is the other half of this craft, the half hardly anybody puts in the photographs. Somebody asked it once in the exact words I have used myself: "What’s the secret to getting the perfect signature line up?"
Here is everything I had tried, in order.
Thick paper to mark the placements. A fresh template for every book, because "I got tired of making new cardstock templates for my sewing holes every time I made a book with slightly different dimensions". A cradle I built myself, which is the thing the groups are full of: "Made a punching cradle out of extra book board and book cloth." Measuring three times instead of twice. An awl. Then a cheap screw punch. Then, on the bad days, "I always mess it up by eye!"
None of it worked, and I had a sentence ready. "I punch signatures, in a punching cradle. Even then the holes don't always come out perfectly from one signature to another. I gave up on perfect and now I shoot for acceptable :)" I wrote that. The smiley face is mine.
The unevenness comes from two places, and not at the same moment.
The first half is registration, where the whole set of marks sits on each fresh sheet. That is the template's job and my hands', entirely mine, and no tool does it for me.
The second half happens after the mark is down, in the last instant the hole is made. Whatever makes the hole has its own behavior then, and you have no say in it. The pliers bite down on your mark and slip off it as they close, so the hole lands off to the side with a ragged edge. An awl pushed or hammered through is steadied by nothing but your hand. One binder, on a cheap screw punch: "I haven't used mine because the large and skinny mechanism is a bit wobbly, the paper stop is also a bit wobbly." Another noticed the result without ever naming the cause: "I noticed that sometimes the punched holes slightly deviates from the paper fold."
Hardly anybody is told the second half exists, so we fix the first one harder. Somebody posted: "Can bookbinding actually be completely even? This only my 2nd bookbinding, and I did use cradle for punching holes, but its still so uneven." She had the cradle. The cradle was never the problem.
And when I showed my mother my first crooked book, she said the thing this whole craft says. It's too easy to see our projects and say "ugh, doesn't look like ones from the store..." And the little flubs and imperfections are what tell people "a human made this." She meant it kindly, every time. I believed her, because the only other explanation was that I was doing something wrong. A classmate once told me to sell on Etsy. I laughed it off, because I knew what the stitching looked like, and I did not open a shop.
A cradle, a template, careful measuring: all of it acts before the hole exists. Not one of them acts during the instant it is cut. So what makes the hole exactly where the mark is, and adds nothing of its own?
The reply I almost scrolled past
One night in March I was reading a thread that was not about signatures at all, and somebody had left a reply underneath it about a tool that makes the hole by turning instead of by driving.
I almost scrolled past it. I had purchased a cheap one on Amazon to try and it is just garbage, and I had been sour on the whole business ever since.
A strike is steadied by nothing but your hand, so the fix is not a steadier strike, it is something that does not strike at all. A jaw bites and slips as it closes, so the fix is not a better jaw, it is something with no jaw. What you need is a hole that is cut in place, not driven through and not squeezed.
That is the whole idea behind the Leathos Hole Puncher and its Spring-Spin-Cut mechanism. You keep your cradle and your template exactly as they are. This replaces the awl or the cheap screw punch, not the setup you already trust.
Why this one, when I had already been burned
I did not order it because of the reply. I ordered it because of what I could check before spending anything.
It is corrosion-resistant brass with steel cutting punches and a hardwood handle, built as a serviceable tool for years of use rather than something you throw out when it dulls. The tips thread in and out, so a different hole size is not a different tool, and when a tip eventually dulls you sharpen it rather than throw it away. That is the opposite of the thing I already had in a drawer.
It turns up in days, and shipping is free. The cheap one I regret took three weeks to arrive from somewhere, because that is what those are.
And there is a thirty-day money-back guarantee, which is the only reason I clicked at all.
How it actually cuts
You hold it over your mark and press straight down, and a rotating mechanism turns that downward pressure into a controlled cutting motion. The cutting action progressively slices its way through instead of relying on impact, which reduces the force applied at any one point around the hole. Because it rotates rather than strikes, there is no hammer blow in the picture at all. A threaded punch system keeps the cutting tip securely aligned while it works, and a spring-assisted return resets it the same way between punches. The circular geometry is designed to produce clean, repeatable holes, and that consistent alignment helps each hole come out uniform, punch after punch.
There is no throat and no fixed margin either. You hold the tool on the work instead of clamping it over an edge, so the hole lands where you set the tip, even in the middle of a large sheet.
It needs a cutting mat or something firm underneath, every time. I did not know that at first and found out the way you would expect.
The first thing I asked, before I had even opened the box
Somebody asked this in public, under the ad, and went a long time without an answer: "Okay, how do you line this up to make sure your holes are consistent and evenly spaced?"
It does not line anything up for you. That is the honest answer. You still measure, you still mark, you still set the tip yourself, on every hole. Mark it badly and the hole goes exactly where you marked it badly.
What goes away is the other half. The part that happened in the last quarter second, after the marking was finished and there was nothing left for me to do about it.
The first book, and then my mother's
First signature, I did exactly what I always do. Marked through the template, nested it in the cradle, held the tool and pressed straight down onto the mat. Nothing dramatic happened, which I want to be honest about. The hole was round, and it was where my mark was. Second signature, the same. Eighth signature, the same.
By the end of that book I had stopped holding each punched signature up against the one before it to see how bad it was. Not because the book was perfect. Because the checking had never been about the book.
By the third book, the woman in my group who has been binding since before I was born picked one up without being asked. "Your holes are different." "Different how?" "They're all the same. Every one of them." I told her about the punch and got the face. "It's a hole," she said. "A hole is a hole."
Then my mother. Second week: four signatures on her table, punched, squared up on top of each other. Not held up to the light, not being compared. "They're fine," she said, before I could ask, in the voice you use for something you do not want to have to explain. Third week: "I want to finish the Coptic." The book she got two signatures into, did not like what the stitching was doing, and shut in a drawer.
I went looking for other people who had one
I did not want to be the only one this had worked for, so I went and read what buyers actually say.
Under the ad I first saw, somebody asked the question I had: "Does it work with paper for making journals". People who own one answered it better than any of us.
"I have one for paper. So excited to find this."
"This is so much easier to use than a crop-a-dile and others like them. They’re so cumbersome. This is so easy and versatile. Love it."
On reach, which was never something I thought to want: "It took the place of my crop-o-dile tool which couldn’t reach further into the middle of a 12x12 page".
And the same thing from the other side: "I love mine. Sometimes I just can’t get in far enough with my whole puncture, and this is the perfect solution."
And the honest size of it, from a binder who does not own one at all: "Insuring your holes are the same on all signatures should help align your stitching a bit better." A bit better. That is the size of it.
The things I would still want to know
Collapsible content
Is this just a rebranded cheap punch off a marketplace?
Is this just a rebranded cheap punch off a marketplace?
It is brass, steel and hardwood, built to be serviced rather than replaced, and it turned up in days with free shipping. A clone does not arrive in days and does not survive a month of signatures. Thirty days to decide either way.
So my signatures will line up now?
So my signatures will line up now?
No. It does not line anything up for you, which is why that has a section of its own above. Registration stays yours. What goes is the slip of a jaw closing off target and the wobble of a cheap mechanism.
Does it work on paper, and through a folded signature?
Does it work on paper, and through a folded signature?
Yes, it is built and shown for paper. One folded signature at a time, seated in your cradle, on a cutting mat. It is not meant for a clamped book block lying flat on the table, which is a different job with a different tool.
It's a bit spendy for a hole.
It's a bit spendy for a hole.
Fair, and a binder said it better: "It's a bit spendy, and I don't like the idea of buying a third awl, but that does seem like my best bet." Binders say the same about good screw punches as a category: "Despite the high price tag, it is worth every penny. Excellent quality, couldn't recommend it enough." This is the one you buy after the cheap one failed.
Is it fiddly? Will it last?
Is it fiddly? Will it last?
It is heavy in a way that makes you slow down. Punch sizes change without replacing the tool, and a dull tip is sharpened instead of thrown away. Serviceable, not disposable.
If you are where I was in March
Then the woman who has been binding since before I was born said the sentence I have not stopped thinking about. "You don't need practice. You need reliable techniques and technical aids."
Twenty years of us telling each other the wobble was character, and some of it was just a tool that moved.
My mother's Coptic is finished. It sits on her shelf between two books she did not make, which is where she wanted it, and you cannot tell which one is hers until you pick it up. She has ordered a second punch, for the woman in the group, because that woman has a granddaughter who is learning.
Mine is quieter than that. I gave a journal to my sister-in-law in August, and she opened it in front of me, and I did not say anything. I did not explain the stitching. I did not get in first. Six years of handing people books with a running commentary, and it turns out the commentary was never for them.
None of us has stopped measuring. I still cut a template for every book and I still mark every hole by hand, and if I set my mark a sixteenth out then the hole goes a sixteenth out. That half was always mine and it still is.
If nothing changes, you will hand over the next book and start talking before they have opened it. You will call it acceptable and still know exactly what you are apologizing for. And you will keep not knowing which half of it was ever yours, because there is no way to separate the two while both are still in the room.
The only way to find out is to take one half away and see what is left. Set up your cradle and template exactly as you are used to, mark your holes the way you normally do, and let this take care of the cut itself. There is a thirty-day money-back guarantee so you can find that out on your own signatures, and shipping is free either way.
P.S. If you are the one who put a smiley face after "acceptable", I would just go and look. That was me, and I had written it in public, and I had no idea it was a tool and not a verdict.